Sunday, May 25, 2014

12) PROCUREMENT Management

 |  PROCUREMENT Management
  • Procurement Statement of Work (SOW) is a legal document subject to legal reviews, legal advise should be sought throughout the whole procurement process
  • sellers are external to the project team
  • need to go through all 4 processes for each and every procurement
  • contract elements: offer (seller offer buyer), acceptance (buyer criteria), capacity (physical/financial capabilities), consideration (seller receive), legal purpose (must be legal under law)
  • best if contract is signed after PM is assigned
  • PM needs to understand terms and conditions, identify risks, include procurement time in schedule and involve in negotiations
  • Centralized contracting vs decentralized contracting
  • sole source, single source (preferred), oligopoly (very few sellers)
  • procurement categories: major complexity (high risk), minor complexity (low risk, expensive), routine purchase (Commercial Off the Shelf Products COTS), goods and services (to perform part of our product)
  • a contract is not required to be written, it can be verbal or handshake, for internal projects, formal contract is best
  • procurement applies to actors (as a service)
  • immaterial breach is minor breach
  • point of total assumption (PTA) = Target Cost + (Ceiling Price – Target Price) / % Share of Cost Overrun
  • contract change control system is defined in the procurement management plan but not in the contract
  • Procurement Statement of Work (SOW) is a legal document subject to legal reviews, legal advise should be sought throughout the whole procurement process
  • sellers are external to the project team
  • need to go through all 4 processes for each and every procurement
  • contract elements: offer (seller offer buyer), acceptance (buyer criteria), capacity (physical/financial capabilities), consideration (seller receive), legal purpose (must be legal under law)
  • best if contract is signed after PM is assigned
  • PM needs to understand terms and conditions, identify risks, include procurement time in schedule and involve in negotiations
  • Centralized contracting vs decentralized contracting
  • sole source, single source (preferred), oligopoly (very few sellers)
  • procurement categories: major complexity (high risk), minor complexity (low risk, expensive), routine purchase (Commercial Off the Shelf Products COTS), goods and services (to perform part of our product)
  • a contract is not required to be written, it can be verbal or handshake, for internal projects, formal contract is best
  • procurement applies to actors (as a service)
  • immaterial breach is minor breach
  • point of total assumption (PTA) = Target Cost + (Ceiling Price – Target Price) / % Share of Cost Overrun
  • contract change control system is defined in the procurement management plan but not in the contract
Project Procurement Management ITTOs:

Processes
Inputs
Tools & Techniques
Output
Plan Procurement Management
PM Plan
Requirements Documentation
Risk Register
Activity Resource Requirements
Project Schedule
Activity Cost Estimates
Stakeholder Register
Enterprise Environment Factors
Organization Process Assets
Make-or-buy Analysis
Expert Judgment
Market Research
Meetings
Procurement Management Plan
Procurement SOW
Procurement Documents
Source Selection Criteria
Make-or-buy Decisions
Change Requests
Project Document Updates
Conduct Procurements
PM Plan
Procurement Documents
Procurement SOW
Source Selection Criteria
Seller Proposals
Project Documents
Make-or-buy Decisions
Organization Process Assets
Bidder Conferences Proposal Evaluation Techniques
Independent Estimates
Expert Judgment
Advertising
Analytical Techniques
Procurement Negotiations
Selected Sellers
Agreements
Resource Calendars
Change Requests
PM Plan Updates
Project Document Updates
Control Procurements
PM Plan
Procurement Documents
Agreements
Approved Change Requests
Work Performance Reports
Work Performance Data
Contract Change Control System
Procurement Performance Reviews
Inspections and Audits
Performance Reporting
Payment Systems
Claims Administration
Records Management System
Work Performance Info
Change Requests
PM Plan Updates
Project Documents Updates
OPA Updates
Close Procurements
PM Plan
Procurement Documents
Procurement Audits
Procurement
Negotiations
Records Management System
Closed Procurements
OPA Updates

Plan Procurement Management

  • determine whether to obtain products/services outside of organization
  • identify possible sellers and pre-meeting with them
  • identify explicitly what is needed
  • make-or-buy analysis is a compulsory process, needs to take risks into considerations
  • carefully written terms and conditions can transfer/share risks
  • teaming agreements or joint ventures
  • procurement documents: request for proposal (RFP), invitation for bid (IFB), request for quote (RFQ), request for information (RFI), tender notice, invitation for negotiation, seller initial response
  • the procurement management plan specifies how a project will acquire goods/services from outside, includes: contract type, risk management, constraints and assumptions, insurance requirements, form and format, pre-qualified sellers, metrics used, etc.
  • Procurement Statement of Work (SOW) – performance (describe what can be accomplished), functional (convey the end purpose or result), design (convey precisely what are to be done), can be developed by the seller or buyer – detail enough to allow the potential sellers to decide whether they want/are qualified (at a minimum) to pursue the work
  • Contract Types:
  • Firm Fixed Price (FFP) – the price is fixed, specifications are well known, risk on the seller
  • Fixed Price Incentive Fee (FPIF) – incentives for faster/better than contracted
  • Fixed Price with Economic Adjustment / Economic Price Adjustment (FPEA / FP-EPA) – inflation are taken into account
  • Purchase Order (PO) – for off-the-shelf goods/services with published rates
  • Cost Reimbursable (CR) / Cost Plus – buying the expertise (not the products), outcome is not clear, risk on the buyer, little incentive to control costs on buyer, need invoice audits
  • Cost Plus Fixed Fee (CPFF)
  • Cost Plus Incentive Fee (CPIF) – incentive for performance, sharing of unused money if under/over contracted amount
  • Cost Plus Award Fee (CPAF) – award to be given based on agreed criteria, solely decided by the customer on the degree of satisfaction
  • Cost Plus Percentage of Costs (CPPC) – illegal for contracts with US Government
  • Cost Contract – not profit, for NGO
  • Best Efforts – obligates the seller to utilize best attempts, high uncertainty in meeting the goal
  • Time and Materials (T&M) – (hybrid type) when scope is not known, need constant monitoring to control schedule and cost, simple, for short duration, good for proof-of-concept type projects
  • Point of Total Assumption – (in fixed-price (incentive fee) contracts) in budget overrun, the point at which the seller assumes all additional costs for delivering the product/service
  • PTA = (Ceiling Price – Total Price) / Buyer’s Share Ratio + Target Cost
  • target cost = total cost = estimated cost, total price = total cost + total profit
  • Request for Proposal (RFP) – cost reimbursable contract, functional/performance SOW
  • Invitation for Bid (IFB) / Request for Bid (RFB) – fixed-price contract, design SOW
  • Request for Quote – time and material, any type of SOW
  • Cancellation for Convenience – buyer can cancel and pay up to the point
  • Cancellation for Cause - default by either party, may result in legal actions
  • Escrow – survivability of seller in doubt, put the product in escrow (esp. if seller not give up intellectual properties)
  • Force Majeure – standard disclaimer refers to ‘Acts of God’
  • Indemnification / Liability – responsible party
  • LOI Letter of Intent – not legally binding
  • Privity – the contractor may use sub-contractor, no direct contractual relationship with buyer
  • Retainage – amount to be withheld to ensure delivery
  • Risk of Loss – how the risk is shoulder by the parties
  • Time is of the Essence – delay in delivery will cause cardinal breach of contract
  • Work Made for Hire - all work owned by the buyer
  • Sole Source vs Single Source (preferred vendor – for long-term relationship)
  • Evaluation Criteria: risk, understanding of need, life-cycle cost, technical capability, management approach, technical approach

Conduct Procurements

  • identify the sellers and award the contracts
  • PM may not be the lead negotiator on procurement, but may be present to assist
  • may need senior management approval before awarding the contracts
  • bidder’s conference is a Q&A session with bidders, all bidders receive the same information (bidder are careful not to expose their technical approach during the session => may not have many questions)
  • NOT to have secret meetings or communications with individual vendors
  • may set up qualified sellers lists
  • review seller proposals: weighting systems, independent estimates, screening systems (screen out non-qualified vendors), seller ratings systems (for past performance), expert judgement
  • Contract Negotiations and Tactics
  • Fait Accompli – not negotiable terms
  • Deadline – deadline for deliverables
  • Good Guy/ Bad Guy – one friendly, one aggressive
  • Missing Man – decision maker is missing
  • Limited Authority – not given authority
  • Fair and Reasonable – what is fair?
  • Unreasonable – making unreasonable demands
  • Delay – esp in critical moments
  • Attack – force compliance
  • Agreement is legally binding and should include (PM should NOT attempt to write the agreement):

Control Procurements

  • performed by both seller and buyer
  • manage procurement relationships, monitor contract performance, make change and corrections
  • the procurement administrator may be external to the project team
  • may identify early signs and capture details for pre-mature termination of contract
  • the claims administration process deals with changes/disputes, disputes is best to be settled through negotiation > ADR
  • may need Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) by 3rd parties in case disputes cannot be settled
  • For Fixed Price contracts, look out for Bait and Switch (replace with cheaper materials), look out for excessive change requests
  • For Cost Reimbursable contracts, audit all invoices, look out for additional charges, tie payment to milestones, make sure people with the required skill sets are doing the job
  • For Time and Materials contracts, ensure hours are not padded, follow the milestone dates
  • Contract Change Control System: for handling change requests (define who has the authority to approve changes (usually not the PM, but may be assigned the authority))
  • Work performance data includes: the cost incurred and the invoice needs to be paid
  • OPA may include the seller’s performance

Close Procurements

  • all work are completed, deliverables accepted, claims settled OR terminated by either party
  • at completion / termination of contract
  • prior to administrative closure of Close Project or Phase
  • unresolved claims may be left for litigation after closure
  • settlement of claims/invoices, audit, archive, lessons learned
  • the contract is complete when all the specifications are satisfied, no matter the customer is satisfied with the product or not
  • Procurement Audit is the structured review of the procurement process from Plan Procurement Management through Control Procurements, is used to capture lessons learned from the procurement exercise
  • once a procurement is cancelled, the next process will be the close procurements

11) RISK Management

 |  RISK Management
  • risk identification, management and response strategy impacts every area of the project management life cycle
  • everyone is responsible for identifying risks
  • risk has one or more causes and has one or more impacts
  • risk = uncertainty; risk management: increase the probability of project success by minimizing/eliminating negative risks (threats) and increasing positive events (opportunities)
  • risk attitudes (EEF): risk appetite (willingness to take risks for rewards), tolerance for risk (risk tolerant or risk averse), risk threshold (level beyond which the org refuses to tolerate risks and may change its response)
  • pure (insurable) risk vs business risk (can be +ve or -ve)
  • known risks that cannot be dealt with proactively (active acceptance) should be assigned a contingency reserve or if the known risks cannot be analyzed, just wait for its happening and implement workaround (passive acceptance)
Project Risk Management PITTOs:

Processes
Inputs
Tools & Techniques
Output
Plan Risk Management
Project Management Plan
Project Charter
Stakeholder Register
Enterprise Environment Factors
Organization Process Assets
Analytical Techniques
Expert
Judgment
Meetings
Risk Management Plan
Identify Risks
Risk Management Plan
Cost Management Plan
Schedule Management Plan
Quality Management Plan
HR Management Plan
Scope Baseline
Activity Cost Estimates
Activity Duration Estimates
Stakeholder Register
Project Documents
Procurement Documents
Enterprise Environment Factors
Organization Process Assets
Documentation Reviews
Information Gathering Techniques
Checklist Analysis
Assumptions Analysis
Diagramming Techniques
SWOT Analysis
Expert
Judgment
Risk Register
Perform Qualitative Risk Analysis
Risk Management Plan
Scope Statement
Risk Register
Enterprise Environment Factors
Organization Process Assets
Risk Probability and Impact Assessment
Probability and Impact Matrix
Risk Data Quality Assessment
Risk Categorization
Risk Urgency Assessment
Expert
Judgment
Project Documents Updates
Perform Quantitative Risk Analysis
Risk Management Plan
Cost Management Plan
Schedule Management Plan
Risk Register
Enterprise Environment Factors
Organization Process Assets
Data Gathering and Representation Techniques
Quantitative Risk Analysis and Modeling Techniques
Expert
Judgment
Project Documents Updates
Plan Risk Responses
Risk Management Plan
Risk Register
Strategies for Negative Risk (Threats)
Strategies for Positive Risk (Opportunities)
Contingent Response Strategies
Expert
Judgment
PM Plan Updates
Project Documents Updates
Control Risks
PM Plan
Risk Register
Work Performance Data
Work Performance Reports
Risk Reassessment
Risk Audits
Variance and Trend Analysis
Technical Performance Measurement
Reserve Analysis
Meetings
Work Performance Info
Change Requests
PM Plan Update
Project Document Updates
OPA Updates

Plan Risk Management

  • define and provide resources and time to perform risk management, including: methodology, roles and responsibilities, budget, timing (when and how often), risk categories (e.g. RBS), definitions, stakeholder tolerances (a EEF), reporting and tracking
  • performed at project initiation and early in the Planning process
  • failure to address risks early on can ultimately be more costly
  • analytical techniques include stakeholder risk profile analysis, strategic risk scoring sheets
  • a risk breakdown structure (RBS) (included in the PM Plan) – risks grouped by categories and occurring areas
  • key risk categories: scope creep, inherent schedule flaws, employee turnover, specification breakdown (conflicts in deliverable specifications), poor productivity

Identify Risks

  • determine all risks affecting the project
  • information-gathering techniques: brainstorming, delphi technique [a panel of independent experts, maintain anonymity, use questionnaire, encourage open critique], root cause analysis [performed after an event to gain understanding to prevent similar events from occurring], expert interviewing, SWOT analysis
  • root cause analysis: safety-based (prevent accidents), production-based, process-based (include business process), failure-based, systems-based (all above)
  • root cause analysis tools: FMEA, Pareto Analysis, Bayesian Inference (conditional probability), Ishikawa Diagrams, Kepner-Tregoe
  • Monte Carlo analysis can identify points of schedule risks
  • Influence Diagram - graphical representations of situations showing causal influences, time ordering of events, and other relationships among variables and outcomes.
  • Risk Register (typically not including the risk reserve)
  • The Risk Register may include a risk statement
  • any risk with a probability of >70% is an issue (to be dealt with proactively and recorded in the issue log)

Perform Qualitative Risk Analysis

  • prioritizing risks for further analysis/action and identify high priority risks
  • need to identify bias and correct it (e.g. risk attitude of the stakeholders)
  • qualitative risk assessment matrix (format described in the Risk Management Plan)
  • update to risk register and other related documents
  • risk register update are output of Perform Qualitative Risk Analysis, Perform Quantitative Analysis, Plan Risk Responses and Monitor & Control Risks
  • the scope baseline is used to understand whether the project is a recurrent type or a state-of-the-art type (more risks)
  • risks requiring near-term responses are more urgent to address

Perform Quantitative Risk Analysis

  • the cost, schedule and risk management plan contains guidelines on establishing and managing risks
  • involves mathematical modeling for forecasts and trend analysis
  • data gathering and representation techniques: interviewing, probability distributions [normal distribution (bell shaped curve)],
  • sensitivity analysis (using the tornado diagram as presentation) for determining the risks that have the most impact on the project
  • Failure Modes Effects Analysis (FMEA)
  • FMEA for manufactured product or where risk may be undetectable, Risk Priority Number (RPN) = severity (1-10) x occurrence ([0.07%] 1-10 [20%]) X detectability (1-10 [undetectable]), also a non-proprietary approach for risk management
  • Expected Value / Expected Monetary Value (EMV), probability x impact (cost/effort lost), opportunities (+ve values), threats (-ve values)
  • Monte Carlo Analysis – by running simulations many times over in order to calculate those same probabilities heuristically just like actually playing and recording your results in a real casino situation, ‘S’ curve (cumulative distribution) will result, may use PERT/triangular distribution to model data, may use thousands of data points (a random variable), for budget/schedule analysis
  • Decision Tree Analysis – another form of EMV, branching: decision squares (decision branch – options), circles (uncertainty branch – possible outcomes)

Plan Risk Responses

  • plan response to enhance opportunities and reduce threats
  • each risk is owned by a responsible person
  • the watch list is the list of low priority risks items in the risk register
  • a fallback plan will be used if 1) risk response not effective, 2) accepted risk occurs
  • risk strategies: 1) prevent risk, 2) response to risk, 3) reduce risk, 4) promote opportunities, 5) fallback if risk response fails
  • negative risk strategies: eliminate/avoid (not to use, extend the schedule), transfer (outsource, warranty, insurance), mitigate (reduce the risk by more testing/precautionary actions/redundancy), accept (passive – do nothing or active – contingency)
  • positive risk strategies: exploit (ensure opportunity by using internal resources e.g. reduce cost/use of top talents/new tech), share (contractor with specialized skills, joint venture), enhance (increase likelihood / impact e.g. fast-tracking, add resources etc.), accept
  • passive risk acceptance to be dealt with when the risk occurs
  • Contingency Plan (contingent response strategies) (plan A) are developed for specific risk (when you have accepted a risk) with certain triggers vs Fallback Plan (plan B)
  • Residual Risks – risks remains after the risk response strategy was implemented, may be identified in the planning process (may subject to contingency/fallback planning) They don’t need any further analysis because you have already planned the most complete response strategy you know in dealing with the risk that came before them.
  • Secondary Risks –  risk arises when the risk response strategy was implemented
  • Contingency Reserve: known unknowns (determined risk), part of cost baseline
  • Management Reserve: unknown unknowns (discovery risk), part of project budget
  • The Risk Register is now completed with: risks and descriptions, triggers, response strategy, persons responsible, results from qualitative and quantitative analysis, residual and secondary risks, contingency and fallback, risk budget/time

Control Risks

  • when the above risk planning processes have been performed with due diligence, the project is said to have a low risk profile
  • to check if assumptions are still valid, procedures are being followed and any deviance
  • to identify new risks and evaluate effectiveness of risk response plan
  • any need to adjust contingency and management reserves
  • to re-assess the individual risk response strategies to see if they are effective
  • risk audits deal with effectiveness of risk response and the risk management process
  • risk audits are usually performed by experts outside project team for the whole risk management process
  • reserve analysis and fund for contingencies apply only to the specific risks on the project for which they were set aside
  • workaround: when no contingency plan exists, executed on-the-fly to address unplanned events – still need to pass through normal change control if change requests are needed
  • determine the workaround is performed in control risks

10) COMMUNICATION Management

 |  COMMUNICATION Management
  • assure the timely collection, generation, distribution, storage, retrieval and ultimate disposition of project information
  • very important to the ultimate success of the project
  • message transmission: 7% in word, 38% in vocal pitch, 55% in body language (Albert Mehrabian)
  • don’t wait to communication good/bad news
  • the sender has the responsibility to ensure the receiver correctly understand the message
  • if part of the project is procured, more formal written communication will be expected
Project Communication Management PITTOs:

Processes
Inputs
Tools & Techniques
Output
Plan Communications Management
PM Plan
Stakeholder Register
Enterprise Environment Factors
Organization Process Assets
Communications Requirements Analysis
Communications Technology
Communication Models
Communication Methods
Meetings
Communications Management Plan
Project Document Updates
Manage Communications
Communications Management Plan
Work Performance Reports
Enterprise Environment Factors
Organization Process Assets
Communications Technology
Communication Models
Communication Methods
Information Management System
Performance Reporting
Project Communications
PM Plan Updates
Project Document Updates
OPA Updates
Control Communications
PM Plan
Project Communications
Issue Log
Work Performance Data
Organization Process Assets
Information Management System
Expert
Judgment
Meetings
Change Requests
Work Performance Info
PM Plan Updates
Project Documents Updates
OPA Updates

Plan Communications Management

  • identify the needs for stakeholder communication
  • the who, what, when (frequency), why, where and how of communications needs and the persons responsible
  • time and budget for the resources, escalation path, flow charts, constraints, guideline and templates
  • Communication Methods
    • interactive (multidirectional communication, most effective)
    • push (active, messages sent without validation of receipt)
    • pull (passive, access directly by stakeholders)
  • low context vs high context (japan, more polite)
  • may need to limit who can communicate with whom and who will receive what information
  • (Shannon-Weaver model)Sender-Receiver Model: i) encoded idea, ii) message and feedback, iii) medium, iv) noise level, v) the decoded idea. The sender to ensure info is clear, complete and the recipient correct understands. The recipient to ensure complete message is received (to acknowledge) and provide feedback/response.
  • Effective Listening: feedback, active listening and paralingual (voice expression, nonverbal elements)
  • Communication channels: N (N -1) / 2      // N is the number of team members
  • meetings should facilitate problem solving
  • PM spends 90% of their time on COMMUNICATION activities, 50% of the time is spent on communicating with the team
  • efficient communication: only the required messages
  • effective communication: right timing, right format, right medium

Manage Communications

  • create, collect, distribute, store, retrieve and dispose project information according to the Communication Management Plan
  • ensures good communications, noises managed, stakeholders may feedback on how to improve
  • Communication Barriers vs Communication Enhancers
  • 55% message through body language, 38% through para-lingual, 7% through words used
  • Types of Communications: Formal Written, Formal Verbal, Information Written, Informal Verbal
  • Performance Reporting: status, progress, variance, trend, earned value reports and forecasts, summary of changes, risks and issues
  • PM Plan Update to show the latest performance (against Performance Measurement Baseline)
  • Feedback from stakeholders are to be stored in OPA

Control Communications

  • to ensure optimal information flow for effective stakeholder expectation management
  • issue log is to document the issues and monitor its resolutions (with person responsible)